Two-Minute MBE Question: Evidence (character evidence)
Here, we discuss how to approach the following Evidence MBE question in two minutes. Read the question below then check out the YouYube video below for an answer explanation in less than two minutes!
Evidence MBE Question:
One snowy day, a woman drives her car into her neighbor’s mailbox. The neighbor sues the woman for negligence. The woman wants to offer evidence that she is an extremely careful person into the record. The neighbor objects.
How will the court rule on the neighbor’s objection?
(A) It will be overruled because the defendant may open the door to character evidence.
(B) It will be overruled because habit evidence may be offered in a civil case.
(C) It will be sustained because it is impermissible character evidence.
(D) It will be sustained because it is prejudicial to the neighbor’s case.
Evidence MBE Video Answer Explanation:
Looking for the written answer explanation?
You can find the answer to the Evidence MBE question in the video above or the text below. Just click “SHOW ANSWER”
(C) is the correct answer. Character evidence may be permissibly admitted into evidence in three ways:
First, it may be admitted to prove a witness’s bad character for truthfulness only to impeach the witness. (This is an impeachment category. This is not applicable because the woman is not trying to impeach herself.)
Second, in a civil case, character can only be used when it is an essential element of the case. This comes up in three scenarios: (i) negligent entrustment or hiring, (ii) defamation, and (iii) child custody. That is it. There are many reasons for this. Some scholars think allowing character evidence in a civil case would distract from the main issue of a case and permit the trier of fact to reward the good man and punish the bad, despite what the evidence says. Other scholars say it would substantially increase the amount of mental examinations if character evidence were expanded into areas of psychiatric evaluation and testing. It would also significantly extend the length of trial. So, remember character evidence is only allowed in very limited circumstances in a civil case.
Third, in a criminal case, if character evidence is used it has to be offered by the defendant using reputation or opinion. The prosecution can then rebut with reputation, opinion, or impeaching the defendant’s character witness with specific acts. So, in a criminal case, the defendant must “open the door.” The FRE allows the defendant to “open the door” in criminal cases if he or she so chooses because the defendant has so much at stake. Indeed, he has his life and liberty at stake (unlike a civil case where only money is at stake).
Here, the character evidence is not being used for impeachment so it does not fall into the first category. It is not a criminal case so it does not fall into the third category. This is a civil case, and the character evidence does not fall into one of the three scenarios above (negligent entrustment or hiring, defamation, or child custody) so it cannot be used.
(A) is incorrect because this is not a criminal case.
(B) is incorrect because this is not habit evidence. (Habit evidence is a regular response to a particular set of circumstances—i.e., “Mary takes the stairs two at a time.”) Here, she is trying to describe her driving habits generally.
(D) is incorrect because it would otherwise be considered relevant evidence that is not overly prejudicial. However, character evidence is excluded from civil cases.
Looking to prepare for the bar exam early?
Sign up for our JD Advising Early Bar Prep campaign. We go over early bar prep tips in five minutes a day! It is a great way to get ahead while practicing social distancing and we also include more two-minute MBE questions like this one!
Looking to Pass the Bar Exam?
- 🌟Bar Exam Free Resource Center: Access our most popular free guides, webinars, and resources to set you on the path to success.
- Free Bar Exam Guides: Expert advice on the MBE, the MEE, passing strategies, and overcoming failure.
- Free Webinars: Get insight from top bar exam experts to ace your preparation.
- 🏆One-Sheets: Our most popular product! Master the Bar Exam with these five-star rated essentials.
- Exclusive Mastery Classes: Dive deep into highly tested areas of the MBE, MEE, MPT, and CA bar exams in these live, one-time events.
- Specialized Private Tutoring: With years of experience under our belt, our experts provide personalized guidance to ensure you excel.
- Bar Exam Courses: On Demand and Premium options tailored to your needs.
- Bar Exam Crash Course + Mini Outlines: A great review of the topics you need to know!